for those of you who haven’t been paying attention to the news, the parliament of canada has been (or very soon will be) suspended. this holds true also for those who have been paying attention to the news (if you want a really entertaining explanation of it all, go find the daily show broadcast from dec 8th). i bring this up because there are many similarities between the new zealand and canadian systems of government. and the more of my friends i discuss this system with (and the ways in which it contrasts to our own), the more i find i’m not alone in feeling that it is, to say the least, a completely foreign way of doing things.
basically, the government here works like this: new zealand holds a general election every three years (bet you didn’t know that) for the members of a unicameral parliament and during an election, each citizen casts a vote for a particular party. each party has made it public knowledge beforehand who their prime minister would be if that party gets the majority of the votes (different from our system where you vote for the individual rather than the party, but this is minor compared to the rest of the differences). the type of parliamentary system they have here is called MMP (mixed member proportional --the same kind they have in germany), which means that if a political party gets 5% of the votes, then that party gets 5% of the seats in parliament (WAY different from the US, where the electoral college effectively kills the chances a minor party ever would have of winning anything). so, while there are two main parties plus assorted others, the minor parties actually can have some real power. it is unlikely that any one party (even one of the major ones) will win a clear majority in the election, so nearly always a coalition with the minor parties must be formed. there are other differences between their system and ours, such as the fact that the prime minister has nothing approaching the kind of power within the country that our president has (the PM is pretty much just another member of parliament (MP) with a few additional duties). but no difference between the US government and the NZ government is more striking to an american than the existence of the governor general.
the governor general is the representative of the queen of england in the country. NZ has one, as does canada and most other commonwealth countries. the governor general may have a bunch of jobs. i don’t really know, because when i was originally asking people about what this person does, i couldn’t get past what i considered to be the main power of the governor general: at the queen’s behest, he or she can DISSOLVE THE GOVERNMENT OF THE COUNTRY.
give that a minute to sink in. the queen of england, whom i had always (erroneously, obviously) thought to be a mere figurehead, has the power to disband parliament in a country halfway around the world. now, as the kiwis point out, it’s never happened here. but it did happen in australia back in 1975. and not everyone in australia at the time was happy about it.
this is what is now happening in Canada. the opposition party in the canadian parliament was about to call a vote of no confidence in the prime minister (which would kick him out of office – kinda like impeachment except it seems easier to pull off because I think you just call a vote and don’t have to prove any criminal wrongdoing), so the prime minister asked the governor general of canada to suspend parliament until sometime in january of next year.
now, when i arrived here, of course i knew that new zealand was a commonwealth country and a former british colony. but i had no idea how closely they are tied back to the crown. when i asked a few months ago when NZ got their independence from britain, the answer was “well, kinda never”. before england joined the EU, NZ pretty much exported everything that was going to be exported back to britain. then all of a sudden they had to find other markets for their goods, like asia. until 2006, the supreme court of the land was in england. apparently there is a NZ case that started before 2006 that is still going on over there.
i have tried very hard (no comments from the peanut gallery) not to be the asshole american when i discuss these things with the people over here. and as hard as i’ve tried, i’m sure that on some level i’ve failed. because it’s so…un-american. i’m not talking about MMP (something that i think in some ways is better than the way we do things). but the idea that another country can step in whenever they want and dissolve your government? wtf? mike’s reaction was “yeah, you can TRY to come in here and dissolve our government, but you may want to bring a few soldiers with you”. i think angela thrasher said it best when she said that independence and self governance are what define america. those are our foundation myths, as it were. it’s what every kid is taught in school about what makes us special and different as a country.
i feel it’s important to say that however i may be coming across, i’m not trying to shit on the NZ system. that’s not what this is about. having been here for 5 months now, through an election, i see how it works and there’s a lot about it i like. and i do see one compelling reason why it’s unlikely that NZ would ever change the current arrangement with britain: the founding document of the country, the treaty of waitangi, is between the crown and the maori tribes in NZ and it gave the maori all the rights of british citizens. but if NZ becomes independent, then no more crown, so the treaty basically becomes invalidated. Obviously, new arrangements would be made, but i can certainly see why the maori would be against anything that would get rid of the treaty of waitangi.
the true, deep down reason that i chose this as my blog topic for today, though, is this: sometimes, it takes something really big, like moving across the world, to be able to see and recognize within yourself some of your deepest and most ingrained beliefs and attitudes. i still remember being in third grade and seeing the pictures of all the monuments in washington DC and learning the version of the thanksgiving story where it was all smiles and saying the pledge of allegiance every day. from when you are young, all the sources: school, boy scouts, tv, movies, everything; reinforce what it means to be american. it’s inescapable. and for all my education and regardless of how open-minded i think i am, sometimes it’s really hard not to let your view of the world be colored by preconceived notions of how you think things should be.
and not blurt out “you’ve got to be shitting me” when the nice people who live in the country in which you are a guest tell you about things that are done in a way that you’re not used to.